I recently discussed a challenging case with a colleague, exploring why training or behavior modification might not deliver the desired results. We identified four common reasons:
- The techniques used may be inappropriate or applied incorrectly.
- Lack of client compliance with the training plan.
- Insufficient or inconsistent training.
- Goals that are unrealistic or not specific enough.
Here’s a closer look:
1. Technique Misapplication
A frequent mistake is using corrections like leash pops or yelling as the primary response to unwanted behavior—say, a dog lunging or jumping. While this might temporarily stop the behavior, the dog hasn’t learned a better alternative. Often, the behavior is suppressed out of fear rather than genuine learning, so it usually returns once corrections stop.
For example, a dog lunging on leash may be motivated by fear and trying to “keep other dogs away.” If the dog experiences harsh corrections, it might pause briefly but will likely resume because the underlying fear isn’t addressed.
2. Client Compliance & 3. Training Intensity
Training requires consistent effort and commitment. Without following through daily or allowing enough time, even well-designed plans will struggle to change behavior.
4. Unrealistic or Vague Goals
Clear, achievable goals are essential. Saying “stop barking” without defining when, where, or how is too vague to guide effective training.
Managing vs. Training: The Sofa Example
Sometimes management is the better option. If a dog gets on the sofa only when alone, blocking access to the sofa and offering a comfy dog bed can prevent the behavior without intensive training—prioritizing where your time and effort matter most.
The Bottom Line
Effective behavior change means understanding what motivates the dog, choosing the right techniques, setting clear goals, and maintaining consistency. Suppression alone isn’t enough—true change happens when the dog learns positive alternatives.