I’m sitting at a local eatery, waiting for a friend, when a group arrives with a dog. The owner immediately positions the dog beside her, away from foot traffic. Nice! I think to myself. Someone is paying attention.
The dog remains quiet, likely lying next to her, calm and composed. But then, suddenly, something shifts—a loud noise—and the dog erupts into barking. The owner simply moves the dog away from the service staff, and the situation seems to pass without much concern.
A few minutes later, a restaurant employee empties ice into a bucket, the clatter echoing through the space. Once again, the dog reacts, barking loudly. This time, I hear the owner’s frustrated response: “He really needs more discipline.”
Wait… what?
It’s clear this woman cares for her dog, but somewhere along the way, she learned that barking in response to noise is a matter of “bad manners.” Nothing more.
The Truth About Barking
Here’s what I wish every dog owner understood: when a dog barks at a sudden, loud sound—like ice crashing into a bucket—it’s not because they’re misbehaving or trying to embarrass their owner. It’s because they’re wired to respond this way.
For millennia, dogs have sounded alarms when something unexpected happens. From their perspective, a sudden, jarring noise could indicate a threat. Barking is their way of saying, “Hey! Something’s not right!”
And yet, in this moment, instead of helping her dog feel safe, this owner scolds and blames him—likely because she feels self-conscious about the disturbance.
A Missed Training Moment
To her credit, I noticed she had treats in her pocket. After asking the dog to sit (and, for some reason, giving him a light tap on the nose), she rewarded him with a treat. She was trying. But unfortunately, she missed a powerful opportunity to teach her dog that noises like this don’t have to be scary—in fact, they can predict something positive.
Instead of seeing her dog’s reaction as something to correct, she could have used the moment to educate and reassure. Over time, this could have changed her dog’s emotional response to startling noises.
The Bigger Picture
It’s disheartening to see dogs blamed for perfectly natural, adaptive behaviors. Many owners, despite their best efforts, lack a solid understanding of learning theory and counter-conditioning.
Dogs are not humans in furry coats. They don’t experience our world the way we do—it’s a borrowed experience for them, full of strange sights and overwhelming sounds. If we truly want to help them feel safe, we must consider their perspective.
Rethinking How We React
Before blaming a dog for barking or “misbehaving,” owners should pause and ask: Is my dog really being bad? Or is he just responding to a world that sometimes doesn’t make sense to him?
Dogs will live happier, more secure lives when we stop holding them to human expectations and start supporting them in the ways they actually need. Their behavior isn’t the problem—our lack of understanding often is.
Let’s do better. For them.